Peppermint OS Community Forum

Support => Software & Applications => Topic started by: AndyInMokum on May 14, 2014, 03:59:39 am

Title: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: AndyInMokum on May 14, 2014, 03:59:39 am
Good morning everyone, how's it going.  I've decided that it is time to consolidate my DVD collection, (all of which are legally acquired) onto my HDD.  I've tried using several different packages, (S)Mplayer, Xine,  dvd::rip and VLC.  I can't get any of these to play a DVD let alone rip one.  I've deliberately avoided the CLI ones as, the GUI one are already awkward enough.  I've been searching around for solutions.  The advice I found is all in, "VideoSpeak"   ???.  I have no idea what they are talking about.  It  just adds to the confusion.  I use VLC as my default videa player and very nice it is.  I would like to use it as a DVD ripper too; if it possible.  Can anyone tell me how to set it up to rip DVDs/CDs.  Failing that, advice on any uncomplicated alternative software packages.  Bear in mind that my knowledge of DVDs is - "you put them in the machine and hit play".  Any idiot proof advice would be much appreciated.  Many thanks and have a great day  ;D
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC
Post by: emegra on May 14, 2014, 07:08:32 am
Hi Andy

VLC is my default video viewer as well but I've never successfully ripped DVD's with it, I use Handbrake for that and it's a breeze, you wont find it in the repos ( I've never understood why) but you can download it here http://handbrake.fr/ (http://handbrake.fr/)

Hope this helps

Good luck

Graeme
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC
Post by: AndyInMokum on May 14, 2014, 07:48:08 am
Hi Graeme,  you must be a mind reader.  I found the ppa for the Ubuntu 12.04 version about an hour ago.  I'm testing it as I write.  It looks like a cracking good piece of software.   I just need to test it a bit more.  Its a CPU hungry beast though, that's for sure.  This old girl's maxed out!  That's video.  Video is a complete mystery for me.  Even when I worked for Adobe it baffled me.  I was fine with anything as long as it didn't move.  I still think its witchcraft   ;D.
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC
Post by: emegra on May 14, 2014, 08:33:48 am
Well good luck with it anyway, I've tried a few transcoders in the past and to be honest, never come across anything as good as Handbrake so long as you're happy with .mkv or .mp4 which is fine for me, it is cpu heavy but isn't every transcoder





Graeme
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC
Post by: rjm65 on May 14, 2014, 08:47:38 am
I use DVDFab version 8 but you need a windows machine for that....   it works the best....  one of the reasons I will never switch to linux on my main machine is they won't run my many windows programs like this one, if they did I switch overnight....  ;D
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC
Post by: AndyInMokum on May 14, 2014, 11:10:05 am
I think I can call this one SOLVED.  Handbrake certainly does the job.  Its perfect for what I need.  I guess it isn't in the repositories because of its dubious legality is some countries.  I guess distro developers want to steer clear of controversy.  That and the fact it is not well maintained.  Good enough for me though.  :)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: emegra on May 14, 2014, 04:25:24 pm
Quote
one of the reasons I will never switch to linux on my main machine is they won't run my many windows programs like this one,

Oddly enough that would be my main reason for NOT using these programs because if these companies that produce Windows software are not prepared to support my OS of choice then they don't get my money

 I will only use software that is written to natively run on my operating system (with one exception where I have no alternative) and preferably free as in libre even if it's not as good or as fully featured as some other Windows program and if we all did that maybe these companies would think again about porting their software to Linux




Graeme

Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: mac on May 14, 2014, 07:33:22 pm
...if these companies that produce Windows software are not prepared to support my OS of choice then they don't get my money

Well said!   :)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: PCNetSpec on May 15, 2014, 07:42:20 am
Personally for audio CD ripping I use (or used to use, as I don't do much ripping these days) Asunder:
http://littlesvr.ca/asunder/

Available in the repo's

Previously I used sound-juicer:
http://linuxforums.org.uk/index.php?topic=5642.0
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: rjm65 on May 15, 2014, 08:21:12 am
Quote
one of the reasons I will never switch to linux on my main machine is they won't run my many windows programs like this one,

Oddly enough that would be my main reason for NOT using these programs because if these companies that produce Windows software are not prepared to support my OS of choice then they don't get my money
Sorry but I disagree..  I blame the OS not the makers of the program...  The only reason Linux is not more popular then what 1% of the worlds computers, is the fact that they can't run the windows programs everyone is used to using...  If you linux people really want to gain a foothold on the worlds computers and give microsoft a run for their money, then you have to make linux run the windows programs, otherwise nobody is going to switch ever....  When I try to switch people from xp to linux that is the first thing they say, will it run this program and will it run that program, and when I say no it won't run those programs, they say give me vista or give me win 7 instead....
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: PCNetSpec on May 15, 2014, 08:28:33 am
That's pure rubbish in so many ways.

a) 1% .. yeah right  ::)

b) why the hack should Linux attempt to run Windows applications .. and inevitably run them worse than when they're run natively, therefore making Linux look like a second rate Windows ?

c) Do OS X users winge about it not running Windows apps, or do they say it's a better ecosystem for it ?

d) Linux is ALREADY the world dominator in EVERYTHING except the desktop.

e) Windows is DYING .. why try to emulate a dying OS ? .. and BTW, what do you think will be left when Windows is gone.

f) AAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrggggggggghhhhhhhhhhh .. if Linux ever becomes Windows, I'm off

Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: rjm65 on May 15, 2014, 08:53:29 am
Everyone has their own opinion, and I personally like linux, but since it don't run windows programs I have no use for it as a daily machine, and run windows on a daily basis... If you want to get the masses like me to switch, that is what it going to have to be done.... Windows has the market share because everyone is hooked on their programs.... I don't care to debate this any longer, I am just stating facts as I see them in the world around me....  My daughter was given linux as her first machine and she hates windows, I asked her why she hasn't turned on her win 7 tower in 4 months she told me she likes linux better......  When I was given my first machine there was no linux at that time, there was microsoft dos and win 3.11 for workgroups...  So I was born and raised in dos and windows....  I said I would never switch from windows and I guess I really mean that, until someone makes my programs in linux format, or they make linux run any windows program....  until that happens My Main Machine will be windows.... 
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: mac on May 15, 2014, 09:08:22 am
Sorry but I disagree..  I blame the OS not the makers of the program...  The only reason Linux is not more popular then what 1% of the worlds computers, is the fact that they can't run the windows programs everyone is used to using...  If you linux people really want to gain a foothold on the worlds computers and give microsoft a run for their money, then you have to make linux run the windows programs, otherwise nobody is going to switch ever....  When I try to switch people from xp to linux that is the first thing they say, will it run this program and will it run that program, and when I say no it won't run those programs, they say give me vista or give me win 7 instead....

Nooooo. Bogus!

As I am sure that someone with your apparent computer knowledge understands, vendors choose the platform upon which their offerings are built.  You can't blame the OS for that.

MS is not exactly known for releasing source code so that its various programs can be developed for use in Linux.  The OS can't be blamed for that,  either.

There are a myriad of copyright, propriety and other legal issues that come into play, as well.  The OS can't be blamed for that.

Etc, etc, etc. 

I'm not really sure who "you linux people" are or if giving "microsoft a run for their money" is really their goal. 

"They say give me vista or give me win 7 instead."  Their choice, uninformed as it might be, but still their choice.  If "they" would take the time and invest the effort in learning Linux, as they did in learning Windows, I don't believe they would say such things.  But they won't.  You can't blame the OS for that.

"You have to make linux run the windows programs, otherwise nobody is going to switch ever...."
I did. 

But, hey, to each his own.    :D

However, this is not really the place to extol the virtues of Windows.   >:(


Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: emegra on May 15, 2014, 09:12:51 am
Quote
So I was born and raised in dos and windows.

I was born and raised on Farleys Rusks but I don't eat them any more :)





Graeme
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: PCNetSpec on May 15, 2014, 09:41:03 am
Hehehe .. I'll bet that confuses the Americans (?)

I do .. Farleys Rusks and Mild .. Oh Yeah :)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: VinDSL on May 17, 2014, 07:12:33 pm
Hehehe .. I'll bet that confuses the Americans (?)

I do .. Farleys Rusks and Mild .. Oh Yeah :)

I'm in Arizona and eat London Pub Pickled Onions -- gotta buy them online.

That confuses everyone, too...    :-\
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: Degsy on May 18, 2014, 01:20:42 pm
Are Farley's Rusks still available, Graeme?
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: emegra on May 18, 2014, 02:24:36 pm
Quote
Are Farley's Rusks still available, Graeme?

I'm really not sure I give em up around 1965, but maybe Mark will know apparently he still enjoys one with his beer :)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: PCNetSpec on May 18, 2014, 02:30:21 pm
Tesco's (or pretty much any supermarket)
Farley's are now owned by Heinz .. but even though Heinz call them "Original Farley's Rusks", they were originally an independent bakery in Plymouth (1850's .. they started making Rusks in 1880) bought by Glaxo in 1968, then by Boots in 1986, then by Heinz in 1990.

http://www.tesco.com/groceries/Product/Details/?id=252387000

Nuff info for ya ?
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: rjm65 on May 18, 2014, 02:42:48 pm
LOL  baby cookies and beer what a treat....  LOL   :)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: PCNetSpec on May 18, 2014, 02:55:25 pm
Not just "any old beer" .. has to be M&B Mild ;)

Or possibly Manns original brown ale.

Something sweet and dark .. you get the picture :)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: emegra on May 18, 2014, 03:20:27 pm
It never ceases to amaze me how the subject matter can change on this forum on this one we've went from ripping DVD's to to beer & weaning food,

 If I ever write a book about the Linux community I'm gonna title it "English Beer & Baby Cookies"




Graeme
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: PCNetSpec on May 18, 2014, 03:24:11 pm
:)
Title: Re: Problem Ripping DVDs with VLC [SOLVED]
Post by: AndyInMokum on May 18, 2014, 04:23:52 pm
http://youtu.be/If3SXJeZzMQ (http://youtu.be/If3SXJeZzMQ)

Very definitely  :D!